@milktae_jpg | 64,507 followers
The profusive autotune & the layering makes it hard to distinguish their individual vocals, but that’s what the song is about. Facing death through losing yourself but also reflecting on that “death” to find yourself back. @BTS_twt’s identity is only found through all 7 members—

Tweet Engagement Stats

Stats are based upon replies and quotes of this tweet

Engagement Map

Quotes
Replies
Retweets
Trendsmap

Replies and Quotes

Total of 26 replies and 74 quotes found
In reply to @milktae_jpg
hence the layering of vocals & the overlapped image of 7 on their cover photo. #BlackSwan @BTS_twt #BlackSwanOutNow
 
과한 오토튠과 음을 겹치게 레이어링해서 멤버 개개인의 목소리를 구분하기 힘들게 만들어놓은게 바로 이 곡이 말하고자하는 메시지라는 외랑둥이님 의견.
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
Yes.. this is what I assumed too. It was very hard to distinguish their voices cos they are one.. or losing what identifies them.. your voice is what identifies you. If you lose that distinguish, who are you.. that's why we hear 'what's your name' to what's your thang. Amazing
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
I think the autotune is required for the effect. The ego (self) and the shadow (subconscious) communicating through a mirror that echoes back your own fears and deep buried thoughts and fear of looking into your real self. My thoughts only my opinion.
 
Thank you for your insights. I hope they reach out to all of us.
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
Than why was I already complaining about overuse of autotune for Light. This "stylistic" choice of layering + excess tune made the song sound unfinished, still in need of the raw vocals to be recorded over. We have ears we don't need no philosophical explanation #BlackSwan
 
/ibh/ pantes susah ngebedain siapa yg nyanyi 😭😭😭🤧 keren bgt ih! 🖤
 
black swan hits so different my soul cannot handle this
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
I thought what is wrong with me, how come I don't recognize their voice when I can tell who's sigh in @BTS_twt 😂 I only can figures Namjoon and yoongi.
 
omg milktae legend is back
 
 
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
This was the first thing I thought of when I heard #BlackSwan I don't rlly like to listen to heavily auto tuned music but black swan has this dreamlike vibe and I rlly love it
 
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
im looking for jks vocalsjdjfg
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
I found Taehyung, Namjoon, Yoongi and Hoseok. Still trying to find the other three kings. Taehyung, Yoongi and Hoseok stood out to me most. #BlackSwanOutNow #BlackSwan
 
How is it so easy to digest this information than doing my math homework???????
 
yup. pure art. that’s what it is
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
that's true,i have a hard time trying to distinguish who is singing what part but i still love it
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
Maybe YouTube armys do have rights 😔✊
 
 
 
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
Ahh this is it😳😭😳😭This has been me all day!!! #BlackSwan 💜🖤💜🖤💜🖤 @BTS_twt
 
Okay but tetap berharap jangan sampai sebagian besar lagu di album nanti pakai auto tune yah, soalnya aku penggemar raw vocal 😁
 
ya allah..... the explanation...
 
 
 
these boys never dissapoint even in bit and tiniest its not just a music anymore its an art throught music which they made a lot of layers to color it but at the same time you loosing the color so you need to find it again @damnitICDN
 
in short: art as a representation of their life in depth explanation
 
some choices are just production choices and not that deep at all
 
Ooo that makes sense
 
I’m asking great posters I see to copy and post their comments on the main MV. We need to populate it with thoughts like these 🥰💜💜
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
sounds bad nonetheless🤷‍♀️
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
Aahhh you are back on my tl, welcome back 💜💜💜
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
Bit I still recognized each members voice🙁🙁 #BlackSwan @BTS_twt
 
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
 
In reply to @milktae_jpg
The death of 7 to the born in 1 but still i can distinguish their voices in the song if repeatedly played. 💜💜 #BlackSwanOutNow #BTS_twt
 
Ny friend that make music said the exact thing!! Because they wanted to give the dramatic effect and to suit the meaning of the song!
 
 
nilktae coming from the rest dbejekej
 
 
 
i'm afraid music critics won't get this
 
 
 
I was bit bummed about the heavy use of auto tune but when we think about this...why you do this to me @BTS_twt? 😩 #BlackSwan #BTSisComing
 
 
Was thinking about this too but I wanna hear their pure vocals😭😭😭
 
 
 
Honestly its a very good try. To me, BTS songs are very rich in layers with their distinguished voices. While this time, they use totally a new approach. I am quite confident the magic will hit us when the full album is released with the songs in their order @BTS_twt
 
 
y’all army are geniuses u cant convince me otherwise
 
 
esp: (#BlackSwan ) El profuso autotune y las capas hacen difícil distinguir sus voces individuales, pero de eso se trata la canción. Enfrentar la muerte a través de perderte a ti mismo pero también reflexionar sobre esa "muerte" para encontrarte a ti mismo de nuevo. 👇🏾
 
 
actually i didn't think like that but it is really good perspective.. waow
 
Knew there was something behind all the autotune
 
milktea is back
 
it has beautiful meaning but it ruined the song
 
That’s exactly what I thought it was about and that’s beautiful. Honestly 🥺🥺
 
Ooohhh mangkanya, kok susah bener nebak ini partnya siapa, campur2 sih kyk cap jae
 
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk vcs viu
 
yes yes yes

they are one.
 
 
Over 32 replies and quotes not shown

Retweeters

2,627 retweeters not shown
Register for Trendsmap Access
Login via Twitter to start your free trial now

Don't have a Twitter account? You can also register via Facebook or Instagram

* Analytics, alert and visualisation tools require additional authorisation
Existing users can login

Our trial allows access to only the 8 hour timeframe for this page.

A Trendsmap Plus subscription provides full access to all available timeframes

Signup Now