In reply to @tybutdisagree
auto-tune is being used as an effect to: 1. make BTS' voices less distinguishable from one another. 2. make BTS' voices more robotic and manipulated. 3. make BTS' voices fit a contemporary pop-rap music stylization.
@tybutdisagree | 4,536 followers
Replying to @tybutdisagree
why make BTS' unique voices less distinguishable? it can be to relay that the members' togetherness is their most important quality--the quality that they wish to put across the most. that, in "black swan," they are one united, combined voice--not a group of separate stars.
GIF

Tweet Engagement Stats

Stats are based upon replies and quotes of this tweet

Engagement Map

Quotes
Replies
Retweets
Trendsmap

Replies and Quotes

Total of 9 replies and 24 quotes found
In reply to @tybutdisagree
why make BTS' voices more robotic? it can be to relay the message of one's passion becoming manipulated, to the point wherein it is difficult to identify, difficult to say it's the same as the individualistic, expressive experience it once was. pic.twitter.com/4Ng23NbLe2
 
the most ridiculous part about this "theory" is that rap line did not share lines during their sections. are they not part of this concept? only vocal line have to showcase their "togetherness"?
 
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
I don鈥檛 really like auto tune, but song is amazing, words are amazing , melody is amazing . I want to listen live version of this song and hear our unique 7 voices clearly 馃グ馃挏馃挏 @BTS_twt any way with auto tune it鈥檚 something new and it will sounds good at radios and etc 馃憤馃徎
 
I agree on that so much, I鈥檓 an ARMY and I know exactly how each of their voices sounds, but this time it was really hard to distinguish who鈥檚 who and to even hear more than one voice. It鈥檚 a very smart way of showing the deep meaning behind the song.
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
Part of the beauty of BTS is that each member has a very distinguishable voice. And with their voices they can still make it work. They can be separate stars but they chose not to be because they'd rather promote together as a group.
 
So i'm not gonna trynna distinguish their voices. Am gonna appreciate the whole song n lyrics n the message and then d word. 馃樀馃ゴ馃槶 #BlackSwan #BTSIsComing #BTSingleToday
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
Yess I also noticed that their voices weren鈥檛 clear, it does feel like their submerged under water 馃馃馃
 
氤挫滑鞚 甑硠頃橁赴 頌橂摛鞏挫劀 鞁潃 攵
鞓ろ啝韸 靻 氤挫滑鞚措澕 鞁嫟電 攵勲摛鞐愱矊

#BlackSwan
#BlackSwanOutNow
#BlackSwanArtFilm
@BTS_twt pic.twitter.com/Siew9KVHxJ
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
I had a hard time figuring who was who in the first few listens. It makes for a very different listening experience
 
 
In reply to @motspersonal
I also agree, especially on this part! twitter.com/tybutdisagree/鈥 meanwhile let's just focus on streaming the song, bts clearly put a lot of thought and effort into it. Let's just hope the lead single would have fairer line distribution 馃檹馃檹
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
Thank you for putting into words what I was struggling to explain to my friend whom thought 鈥淏lack Swan just sounds like auto tuned western music鈥 馃槕
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
Yea the song was meant to sound different, I鈥檝e never heard a bts song like this as far as I know , but I believe the reason behind making there voices less powerful and recognizable is because the message is about them feeling like the passion & emotions are at a low 馃枻
 
THIS. THIS . THIS !!!!!!!!!
 
 
In reply to @tybutdisagree
ridiculous autotune just sound bad and your theory doesnt pan out since we can hear RL individually, they only blended the VL
 
鈥淭he whole is greater than the sum of its parts.鈥 (Aristotle)

@BTS_twt #BlackSwan #BlackSwanOutNow #MOTS7
 
 
睾乇賯丕賳賷賳 亘丕賱丿賲賵毓 賲丕 賳卮卮賵賮
 
 
 
 
Yeah that鈥檚 why stop asking about line distribution in black swan because it鈥檚 bts remember they have full control over their production and they know what they are doing so let us not assume things and enjoy what they鈥檝e released
 
'they are one united, combined voice--not a group of separate stars'
馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ馃ズ
 
appreciate the song because they worked hard for it and please don't complain about the line distribution 馃檮
 
solo stans go cry about it 馃檮
 
la penser貌 sempre in questo modo
 
Nonsense and BS sugarcoated!
Sad that an artist has fans like these who can't even value thier uniqueness. 馃あ
 
ASDFGHHKLL I LOVE U
 
 
Thank u @tybutdisagree and @elliotsang I was wondering why I felt so unsettled yet mesmerized by #BlackSwan I buy ur analysis 100%馃槉
 
Over 1 replies and quotes not shown

Retweeters

1,187 retweeters not shown
Register for Trendsmap Access
Login via Twitter to start your free trial now

Don't have a Twitter account? You can also register via Facebook or Instagram

* Analytics, alert and visualisation tools require additional authorisation
Existing users can login

Our trial allows access to only the 8 hour timeframe for this page.

A Trendsmap Plus subscription provides full access to all available timeframes

Signup Now